The Problem of Welfare Reform
Monday, 23 November 2009 08:01

Animal Rights Advocates Inc. hosted a forum yesterday looking at the structure of animal welfare legislation in Western Australia and the lmiitations thereof.

It often comes as a surprise to people that ARA doesn't pursue changes in legislation as an avenue to help animals. Indeed we believe that welfare reforms:

  • do not provide significant protection for animal interests;
  • make the public feel better about exploiting animals;
  • may actually increase net suffering;
  • further entrenches the view of animals as commodities; and
  • divert resources from vegan/abolitionist education.

While we believe that most animal advocates have the best interests of animals at heart we think that many of the campaigns that are currently run within the animal protection movement are strategically misguided and philosophically inconsistent with actually ending animal exploitation. That may sound harsh but we think that it is important that there is critical reflection on what we put our energies into rather than just going along with the campaigns of the large animal organisations that have progressively become more conservative over time.

We encourage people who either do not understand why ARA does not run welfare campaigns, or think we should, to read the following arguments and reflect on what this means for their activism. We'd also like to hear your thoughts so get in touch on info@ara.org.au

The Four Problems of Animal Welfare: In a Nutshell

Gary L. Francione provides a short response to those animal advocates who promote the welfarist approach and who do not understand why this approach is inconsistent with the rights/abolitionist position.

Abolitionism versus New Welfarism: A Contrast in Theory and Practice

Dan Cudahy explores the differences in where the animal protection movement is headed.

Animal Rights vs Welfare Reforms: An Activist Reader

A collection of articles compiled by ARA to provide an abolitionist critique of welfare reforms:
 
mediareleases
dark-emu
subscribelogo.jpg
paypalogo1.jpg
animalrights.jpg

Animal Rights

The animal rights philosophy is the right of all sentient beings to not be the property of others...

govegan.jpg

Go Vegan

Adopt a cruelty-free vegan lifestyle and make a powerful statement against violence...

getactive.jpg

Get Active

Get information to learn how to be an effective activist for other animals...

We acknowledge the Noongar people as the original custodians of this land.